Performance of ‘Honeycrisp’ Apple Trees on Several Size-Controlling Rootstocks in the 2014 NC-140 Rootstock Trial after Ten Years
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.71318/zfq46c93Keywords:
TCA – trunk cross-sectional area, CRS – cumulative rootstock suckers, CYE – cumulative yield efficiency, FW – fruit weight, tall spindle training.Abstract
In 2014, a multi-year orchard experiment of apple Malus x domestica (Borkh) was established at 13 locations in Canada, Mexico, and the United States using ‘Honeycrisp’ as the scion. Seventeen dwarf and semi-dwarf rootstock genotypes were tested, specifically: Budagovsky.10 (B.10), the Cornell-Geneva rootstocks G.11, G.202, G.214, G.30, G.41, G.890, G.935, G.969, the Malling rootstocks M.7, MM.106, and the Vineland rootstocks V.1, V.5, V.6, and V.7. The industry standard Malling rootstocks M.26 EMLA and M.9-T337 were included for comparison purposes. Tree mortality, trunk cross-sectional area, tree canopy size, amount of rootstock suckering, yield, and fruit number were measured annually. All measured parameters were influenced by location and rootstock, and the interaction of these two factors was significant. Overall, after 10 years and averaged over all locations, rootstock vigor separated into three distinct rootstock classes: those similar to M.9-T337 (G.11), those similar to M.26 EMLA (G.935, G.41, B.10, G.214, G.969), and those more vigorous than M.26 EMLA (V.1, G.30, M.7, V.7, MM.106, V.6, G.890, V.5). G.202 performance was unusual and therefore was omitted from data analysis. Cumulative yields were generally greater on trees with the highest vigor. Averaged over all locations, all Geneva, Vineland, and Budagovsky rootstocks had cumulative yields higher than the industry standards M.9-T337 and M.26 EMLA. The newer rootstocks B.10, V.5, V.6, V.7 and all the Geneva rootstocks, had good to excellent cumulative yields. G.890 stood out as having exceptional cumulative yield among all the rootstock genotypes evaluated. Averaged over all locations, cumulative yield efficiency was greatest for M.9-T337 and all the Geneva rootstocks, as well as B.10. Overall, the strong rootstock by location interaction on cumulative yield observed in this trial illustrates the importance of testing rootstocks at a regional level. These results are reflective of orchard vigor and yields after 10 years and provide apple producers with performance indicators to make more informed decisions concerning rootstock selection for their orchard training systems and planting locations using a weak scion cultivar.
References
Autio WR, Krupa J. 2001. Rootstock effects on Ginger Gold apple trees. Fruit Notes 66(5):51.
Autio WR, Krupa J, Clements JM. 2005. A comparison of Vineland apple rootstocks and M. 26 EMLA in the 1996 McIntosh rootstock trial. Fruit Notes. 71:1.
Autio W, Robinson T, Black B, Blatt S, Cochran D, Cowgill W, Hampson C, Hoover E, Lang G, Miller D, Minas I. 2017. Budagovsky, Geneva, Pillnitz, and Malling apple rootstocks affect ‘Honeycrisp’ performance over the first five years of the 2010 NC-140 ‘Honeycrisp’ apple rootstock trial. J Am Pomol Soc. 71(3):149-166.
Autio WR, Robinson TL, Black B, Bradshaw T, Cline JA, Crassweller RM, Embree CG, Hoover EE, Hoying SA, Iungerman KA, Johnson RS, Lang G, Parker ML, Perry RL, Reighard GL, Schupp JR, Stasiak M, Warmund M, Wolfe D. 2011. Performance of ‘Fuji’ and ‘McIntosh’ apple trees after 10 years as affected by several dwarf rootstocks in the 1999 NC-140 Apple Rootstock Trial. J Am Pomol. Soc. 65(2):2-20.
Autio W, Robinson T, Blatt S, Cochran D, Francescatto P, Hoover E, Kushad M, Lang G, Lordan J, Miller D, Minas I. 2020a. Budagovsky, Geneva, Pillnitz, and Malling apple rootstocks affect ‘Honeycrisp’ performance over eight years in the 2010 NC-140 ‘Honeycrisp’ apple rootstock trial. J Am Pomol Soc. 74(4):182-195.
Autio W, Robinson T, Black B, Crassweller R, Fallahi E, Hoying S, Parker M, Quezada RP, Reig G, Wolfe D. 2020b. Budagovsky, Geneva, Pillnitz, and Malling apple rootstocks affect ‘Fuji’ Performance over eight years in the 2010 NC-140 ‘Fuji’ Apple rootstock trial. J Am Pomol Soc. 74(4):196-209.
Auvil TD, Schmidt TR, Hanrahan I, Castillo F, McFerson JR, G. Fazio G. 2011. Evaluation of dwarfing rootstocks in Washington apple
replant sites. Acta Hortic. 903:265-271 https://doi.org/10.17660/ActaHortic.2011.903.33.
Baldassi C, Roeder S, Serra S, Musacchi S. Rootstock and crop load affect maturity and quality of ‘Honeycrisp’ apples under Washington State growing conditions. Sci Hort. 343:114068. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.scienta.2025.114068.
Bradshaw T, Autio W, Blatt S, Clements J, Einhorn T, Elkins R, Fallahi E, Francescatto P, Lordan J, Minas I, Peck G. 2023. Performance of ‘Modi®’ apple trees on several Geneva rootstocks managed organically: Five-year results from the 2015 NC-140 Organic Apple Rootstock Trial. J Am Pom Soc. 77(1):14-27.
Campbell T, Kalcsits L. 2024. Strategies to overcome biennial bearing in apple–A review. Eur J Agron. 158, p.127213.
Cline JA, Hunter DM, Bonn WG, Bijl M. 2001. Resistance of the Vineland series of apple rootstocks to fire blight caused by Erwinia amylovora. J Am Pom Soc. 55(4):218-221.
Cline JA, Gardner J. 2005. Commercial production of Honeycrisp apples in Ontario. Ontario Ministry of Agriculture, Food and Rural Affairs. Agdex 211/32. Queen’s Printer of Ontario, Toronto.
Cline JA, Autio W, Clements J, Cowgill W, Crassweller R, Einhorn T, Fallahi E, Francescatto P, Hoover E, Lang G, Lordan J, Moran R, Muehlbauer M, Musacchi S, Stasiak M, Parra Quezada R, Robinson T, Serra S, Sherif S, Wiepz R, and Zandstra J. 2021a. Early performance of ‘Honeycrisp’ apple trees on several size-controlling rootstocks in the 2014 NC-140 rootstock trial. J Am Pomol Soc. 75(4):189-202.
Cline JA, Autio W, Clements J, Crassweller R, Fallahi E, Kon T, Muehlbauer M, Reighard G, Oulette DR. 2021b. Early performance of ‘Fuji’ apple trees on several size-controlling rootstocks in the 2014 NC-140 rootstock trial. J Am Pomol Soc. 75(4):203-215.
Cline JA, Black B, Coneva E, Cowgill W, Crassweller R, Fallahi E, Kon T, Muehlbauer M, Reighard G, Oulette DR. 2023. Performance of ‘Fuji’ Apple Trees on several size-controlling rootstocks in the 2014 NC-140 rootstock trial after eight years. J Am Pomol Soc. 77(4):226-243
Cummins J, Aldwinckle HS, Robinson TL, Fazio G. 2013a. Apple tree rootstock named ‘G. 969’. Cornell University and US Department of Agriculture, U.S. Patent Application 12/925,309. (Filed 10 Oct 2010, granted 10 Dec 2013).
Cummins J, Aldwinckle HS, Robinson TL, Fazio G. 2013b. Apple tree rootstock named ‘G. 890’. Cornell University and US Department of Agriculture, 2013b. U.S. Patent Application 12/931,745. (Filed 9 Feb 2011, granted 15 Jan 2013).
Dallabetta N, Giordan A, Guerra A, Pasqualini J. 2018a. The performance of Geneva apple rootstocks in the province of Trento. Acta Hort. 1228:153-159. https://doi.org/10.17660/ActaHortic.2018.1228.23.
Dallabetta N, Guerra A, Pasqualini J, Fazio G. 2021. Performance of semi-dwarf apple rootstocks in two-dimensional training systems. HortScience. 56(2):234-241. https://doi.org/10.21273/HORTSCI15492-20.
Dallabetta N, Guerra A, Pasqualini J, Giordan M. 2018b. The performance of different rootstocks in varying soil conditions. Acta Hort. 1228:229-234. https://doi.org/10.17660/ActaHortic.2018.1228.34.
Dennis Jr F. 2000. The history of fruit thinning. Plant Growth Regul. 31:1–16.
Embree CG, Nichols DS. 2005. Bioregulators improve fruit size and color and reduce crop load and annual bearing of Honeycrisp apples. Can J Plant Sci. 85:453–455.
Fazio G, Wan Y, Kviklys D, Romero L, Adams R, Strickland D, Robinson TL. 2014. Dw2, a new dwarfing locus in apple rootstocks and its relationship to induction of early bearing in apple scions. J Am Soc Hort Sci. 129(2):87-98. https://doi.org/10.21273/JASHS.139.2.87.
Fazio G, Robinson T, Aldwinckle H. 2018. Geneva® apple rootstock comparison chart v.4. 6 Mar 2025. https://ctl.cornell.edu/wp-content/uploads/plants/GENEVA-Apple-Rootstocks-Comparison-Chart.pdf.
Ferree DC, Schmid JC, Bishop BL. 2002. Survival of apple rootstocks to natural infections of fire blight. HortTechnology 12:239–241.
Ferree DC, Warrington IJ. 2003. Apples: botany, production, and uses. CABI Publishing, Wallingford, Oxon, UK.
Greene DW, Weis SA. 2001. Evaluation and growing of Honeycrisp in New England. Compact Fruit Tree. 34(4):100-103.
Griffith C, Einhorn TC. 2022. The role of xylem in bitter pit incidence of apple: a review. J Am Pomol Soc. 76(3): 125-135.
Hampson CR. 2012. The performance of four vineland apple rootstocks in British Columbia, Canada. J Am Pomol Soc. 66(1):23–27.
Hoblyn TN, Grubb NH, Painter AC, Wates BL. Studies in biennial bearing. J Pomol Hortic Sci. 1937(14):39–76.
Howard NP, Tillman J, Vanderzande S, Luby JJ. 2019. Genetics of zonal leaf chlorosis and genetic linkage to a major gene regulating skin anthocyanin production (MdMYB1) in the apple (Malus × domestica) cultivar Honeycrisp. PLoS ONE 14(1): e0210611. https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0210611.
Johnson S, Roper T, Dai X. 2020. Managing suckers around fruit trees. All Current Publications. Paper 2144. https://digital
commons.usu.edu/extension_curall/2144. [accessed 11 July 2025]
Lawrence BG, Fazio L. Gonzalez Nieto, Robinson TL. 2025. Rootstock effect on horticultural performance and fruit quality is not uniform across five commercial apple cultivars in western NY Front Plant Sci.16:1552625. https://doi.org/10.3389/fpls.2025.1552625.
Link H. 2000. Significance of flower and fruit thinning on fruit quality. Plant Growth Regulat. 31:17–26.
Lordan J, Fazio G, Francescatto P, Robinson T. 2018. Effects of apple (Malus x domestica) rootstock on vigor and yield response on ‘Honeycrisp.’ Acta Hort. 1228:149-152. https://doi.org/10.17660/ActaHortic.2018.1228.22.
Lordan J, Fazio G, Francescatto P, Robinson TL. 2019. II. Horticultural performance of ‘Honeycrisp’ grown on a genetically diverse set of rootstocks under Western New York climatic conditions. Sci Hort 257:108686. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.scienta.2019.108686.
Marini RP. 2020. Effects of growing location on fruit tree root suckers. J Am Pomol Soc. (APS) 74:210-218 http://www.pubhort.org/aps/74/v74_n4_a3.htm.
Marini RP, Barden, JA. 2004. Yield, fruit size, red color, and a partial economic analysis for 'Delicious' and 'Empire' in the NC-140 1994 Systems Trial in Virginia. J Am Pomol Soc. 58(1):4-11.
Marini RP, Anderson JL, Autio WR, Barritt BH, Cline JA, Cowgill WP, Crassweller RC, Garner RM, Gauss A, Godin R, Greene GM. 2006a. Performance of ‘Gala' apple trees on 18 dwarfing rootstocks: A ten-year summary of the 1994 NC-140 rootstock trial. J Am Pomol Soc. 60(2):69-83.
Marini RP, Barritt BH, Brown GR, Cline J. 2006b. Performance of 'Gala' apple on four semi-dwarf rootstocks: A ten-year summary of the 1994 NC-140 semi-dwarf rootstock trial. J Am Pomol Soc. 60:58-69.
Marini RR, Autio WR, Black B, Cline J, Crassweller RM, Domoto PA, Hampson C, Moran R, Quezada RA, Robinson T, Stasiak M. 2012a. The influence of crop density on annual trunk growth of 'Golden Delicious' apple trees on three rootstocks at 11 Locations. J Am Pomol Soc. 66(4):183-195
Marini RP, Autio WR, Black B, Cline JA, Cowgill Jr WP, Crassweller R, Domoto P, Hampson C, Moran R, Parra-Quezada RA, Robinson T. 2012b. Summary of the NC-140 apple physiology trial: the relationship between 'Golden Delicious' fruit weight and crop density at 12 locations as influenced by three dwarfing rootstocks. J Am Pomol Soc. 66(2):78-90.
Marini RP, Fazio G. 2018. Apple rootstocks: history, physiology, management, and breeding. Hort Rev. 45:197-312. https://doi.org/10.1002/9781119431077.ch6.
Nieto LG, Reig G, Lordan J, Sazo MM, Hoying SA, Fargione MJ, Reginato GH, Donahue DJ, Francescatto P, Biasuz EC and Fazio G. 2023. Long-term effects of rootstock and tree type on the economic profitability of ‘Gala’, ‘Fuji’ and ‘Honeycrisp’ orchards performance. Sci Hort. 318: p.112129. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.scienta.2023.112129.
Racsko, J. 2019. Apple rootstock suckers. https://apples.extension.org/apple-root-suckers/#:~:text=Root%20suckers%20cause%20problems%20for,entry%20point%20for%20fire%20blight. [Accessed 11 July 2025].
Reig G, Lordan L, Fazio G, Grusak MA, Hoying S, Cheng L, Francescatto P, Robinson T. 2018. Horticultural performance and elemental nutrient concentrations on ‘Fuji’ grafted on apple rootstocks under New York State climatic conditions. Sci Hort 227:22-37. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.scienta.2017.07.002.
Reig G, Lordan J, Sazo MM, Hoying S, Fargione M, Reginato G, Donahue DJ, Francescatto P, Fazio G, Robinson TL. 2019. Long-term performance of ‘Gala’, Fuji’ and ‘Honeycrisp’ apple trees grafted on Geneva® rootstocks and trained to four production systems under New York State climatic conditions. Sci Hort. 244:277-293. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.scienta.2018.09.025.
Robinson TL, Fazio G, Aldwinckle HS, Hoying SA, Russo N. 2006. Field Performance of Geneva® apple rootstocks in the Eastern USA. Sodininkystė ir daržininkystė 25:181-191.
Robinson T, Lopez S, Iungerman K, Reginato G. 2009. Crop load management for consistent production of Honeycrisp apples. New York Fruit Quarterly. 17(1):24-28.
Robinson TL, Fazio G, Aldwinckle HS. 2012. Characteristics and performance of four new apple rootstocks from the Cornell-USDA apple rootstock breeding program. Acta Hort. 1058:651-656. https://doi.org/10.17660/ActaHortic.2014.1058.85.
Robinson TL, Fazio G, Aldwinckle HS. 2014. Characteristics and performance of four new apple rootstocks from the Cornell-USDA apple rootstock breeding program. Acta Hort. 1058:651-656. https://doi.org/10.17660/ActaHortic.2014.1058.85.
Robinson T, Hoying S. 2011. The tall spindle planting system: Principles and performance. Acta Hort. 903:571-579. https://doi.org/10.17660/ActaHortic.2011.903.79.
Robinson TL, Hoying SA, Reginato GA. 2006. The tall spindle apple production system. New York Fruit Quarterly 14:21-28.
Robinson TL, Hoying SA, Fazio G. 2008. Performance of Geneva® rootstocks in on-farm trials in New York state. Acta Hort. 903:249-255. https://doi.org/10.17660/ActaHortic.2011.903.31.
Robinson T, Lopez S. 2010. Crop load affects 'Honeycrisp' fruit quality more than nitrogen, potassium, or irrigation. Acta Hort. 940:529-537. https://doi.org/10.17660/ActaHortic.2012.940.76.
Serra S, Leisso R, Giordani L, Kalcsits L, Musacchi S. 2016. Crop load influences fruit quality, nutritional balance, and return bloom in ‘Honeycrisp’ apple. HortScience 51:236–244.
US Apple. Available online: https://usapple.org/news-resources/2024-25-apple-production-will-reach-nearly-260-million-bushels#:~:text=Varietal%20Mix,increase%20dramatically%20in%20the%20future.%E2%80%9D. [accessed on 24 March 2025].
Valverdi NA, Kalcsits L. 2021. Rootstock affects scion nutrition and fruit quality during establishment and early production of 'Honeycrisp' Apple. HortScience 56(2):261-269. https://doi.org/10.21273/HORTSCI15488-20.
Zhou B, Sun J, Liu S, Jin W, Zhang Q, Wei Q, Zhou BB, Sun J, Liu SZ, Jin WM, Zhang Q, Wei QP. 2016. Dwarfing apple rootstock responses to elevated temperatures: a study on plant physiological features and transcription level of related genes. J Integr Agric. 15:1025–1033.
Downloads
Published
Issue
Section
License
Copyright (c) 2025 J.A. Cline, W. Autio, J. Clements, W. Cowgill, R. Crassweller, T. Einhorn, P. Francescatto, L. Gonzalez Nieto, E. Hoover, G. Lang, J. Lordan, R. Moran, M. Muehlbauer, S. Musacchi , Dr. R. Parra Quezada, J. Schupp, S. Serra, S. Sherif, T. Robinson, R. Wiepz, J. Zandstra (Author)
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial 4.0 International License.
The American Pomological Society and Editors cannot be held responsible for the views and opinions expressed by individual authors of articles published herein. This also applies to any supplemental materials residing on this website that are linked to these articles. The publication of advertisements does not constitute any endorsement of products by the American Pomological Society or Editors.
